Greatest Royal Rumble: I’ll Go With The Slightly Less Great Version
IMG Credit: WWE
Greatest Royal Rumble
Date: April 27, 2018
Location: King Abdullah International Stadium, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia
Commentators: Corey Graves, Michael Cole, Byron Saxton
It’s finally time for a show that feels like the build has been going on for months. This is one of the biggest cards the WWE has ever produced and it’s hard to say where a lot of the matches are going to go. We’ve got seven title matches, two big time singles matches and the fifty man Royal Rumble, meaning this show could run longer than Wrestlemania. Let’s get to it.
We open with the National Anthems of Saudi Arabia and the USA.
The stadium looks mostly full, though there are some very visible pockets of empty seats.
The opening video is a countdown with the other big matches shown in between the numbers. We switch to the regular opening video looking at the rest of the matches.
The announcers welcome us and say this is a step in the country’s progression. Oh I’m sure that’s going to go over well.
HHH vs. John Cena
The crowd is WAY into things to start, at least for HHH’s entrance. Cena has a tunnel of kids to run though, which is one of the universally good ideas. HHH shoves him down to start so Cena does the same for a staredown. We hit the test of strength until HHH kicks him in the ribs. They’re at a very slow pace to start until Cena gets two off a rollup. HHH grabs a sleeper but Cena fights back, only to get clotheslined down.
The facebuster gets two so Cena grabs the ProtoBomb but gets caught in a belly to back suplex. HHH does his own You Can’t See Me (plus a crotch chop) to set up the Pedigree, which is reversed into a whip over the corner. Back in and the spinebuster gets two on Cena, who slugs away and grabs the STF. HHH is in the rope in a hurry and hits another spinebuster (you don’t seen him repeat that too often) for two more.
Cena is right back with another ProtoBomb into the Shuffle, followed by the AA for a close two. Another AA is countered into the Pedigree for two in the most obvious sequence ever. The STF goes on but HHH reverses into a Crossface which is reversed into another AA. A catapult into the corner sets up the third AA to put HHH away at 15:52.
Rating: B+. Well you knew these two would have a good match. It took some time to get going but once they hit their stride it got better in a hurry. Cena winning is fine as the fans are going to love him, just for the charisma alone. If nothing else he probably has to get on the first place out of the country and back to Hollywood. Good match and a smart choice for an opener.
Post match Cena thanks the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and all of the fans who allowed him to be here.
Cruiserweight Title: Kalisto vs. Cedric Alexander
Cedric is defending. They fight over the wristlocks to start and then trade headscissors into safe landings. Kalisto sends him outside for a springboard flip dive but Cedric is right back in with a flip dive of his own. Back in and we hit the waistlock to keep Kalisto down, with Alexander muscling him down.
Kalisto fights up and scores with an enziguri, followed by a springboard crossbody for no cover. A wicked Michinoku Driver gets two on Kalisto but he kicks Cedric in the head again. Kalisto puts him on top and, after a slugout on the ropes, hits a springboard C4 for two. The Lumbar Check is countered into a sloppy hurricanrana but the Salida Del Sol is countered into the Lumbar Check to retain Cedric’s title at 10:08.
Rating: B-. That waistlock was a bit of a match killer but the rest of the stuff after that was solid. They were really getting going there near the end and it was a better match. The lack of a story didn’t help things though and they needed a little something else to make it work. Cedric can move on to Buddy Murphy, but that’s still not exactly going to ignite 205 Live.
Raw Tag Team Titles: The Bar vs. Matt Hardy/Bray Wyatt
The titles are vacant coming in due to Braun Strowman and a ten year old (who carried the team) vacating the titles after Wrestlemania. Hardy wants to delete the Bar but settles for elbowing Cesaro down. Wyatt comes in and runs Cesaro over and it’s time for the applause. A neckbreaker gives Matt two but Sheamus shoves the Twist of Fate away. Matt gets shoved outside for no logical reason before Sheamus takes him back inside for a front facelock. It’s off to Cesaro for a chinlock as Cole points out that the fans here might not get Matt. To be fair, most Americans don’t either.
Cesaro gets two off a gutwrench suplex and there’s a double backbreaker to keep Matt in trouble. Matt rolls away though and the hot tag brings in Wyatt to clean house. With Matt down though, the double White Noise gets two and Wyatt is down as well. Sheamus loads up the Brogue Kick but Wyatt spiders up for Sister Abigail. The elevated Twist of Fate gives Matt the pin at 8:52.
Rating: C. This just kind of happened and there’s nothing wrong with that. The ending was never in doubt and Matt and Bray are fine as champions. I’m not sure who going to take the titles from them as the division has some teams to it, but most of the aren’t exactly the kind of teams that would take the titles.
We recap the US Title match, which was Jeff Hardy winning a quick title match over Jinder Mahal, who was fresh on Raw. Hardy then moved to Smackdown so Mahal is trying to get the title back in a Raw vs. Smackdown match.
US Title: Jeff Hardy vs. Jinder Mahal
Hardy is defending and has a bad knee coming in. Mahal runs him over to start but gets sent outside for a dive off the steps. Sunil Singh offers a quick grab of the leg though and Mahal gets in a shot to take over. We hit the chinlock for a good while until Jeff pops up for a Twist of Fate. Back up and Mahal tries a gutbuster but gets hit with the legdrop between the legs for two instead.
The Whisper in the Wind misses but Mahal goes down anyway (I thought he dropped a quick elbow) in a horrible looking botch. Jeff hits the corner dropkick and another Twist of Fate, setting up the Swanton to retain at 6:19. Hardy’s knee injury from Smackdown was never a factor.
Rating: D. I’m surprised by the ending but anything that involves Mahal losing and his stock value being lowered is a good thing. This also changes the likely outcome of the Intercontinental Title match but Hardy winning is a smart idea. He could be a major player on Smackdown and taking the title from him so soon would have been ridiculous.
It’s time for the national prayer so we go to the Kickoff Show panel.
Video on the changes in Saudi Arabia, including how women are being treated better. I’ll be moving on.
Chris Jericho is ready to win the Greatest Royal Rumble over stars like Kurt Angle, Mark Henry, Rey Mysterio and MOJO RAWLEY. Jericho doesn’t know the interviewer’s name so Mike Rome JUST MADE THE LIST.
We run down the remaining card.
Daniel Bryan wants to win as well because he needs to be back in the ring.
Smackdown Tag Team Titles: Usos vs. Bludgeon Brothers
The Usos are challenging with Rowan dropkicking Jey down early on. A pumphandle backbreaker gets two and we hit the fists crushing Jey’s head. Cole says this was made famous by the “late great” Sgt. Slaughter. In case this has you confused, Slaughter is very much alive. Harper misses a big boot in the corner and the hot tag brings in Jimmy to speed things up.
The running Umaga Attack hits Harper in the corner and Rowan gets knocked to the floor. There’s a double superkick to Harper and the Superfly Splash gets two. Harper runs Jey over and slaps Rowan to fire him up. The double powerbomb finishes Jimmy and retains the titles at 5:11.
Rating: D+. The Usos’ flurry was nice but this was only a few steps above a squash. That’s what the match needed to be too as the Brothers can be established as monsters for a long time to come. Since the show is so long by definition, it’s good to have something go fast like this one and this was their best option.
We recap the Intercontinental Title match, which is just a video about ladder matches.
Intercontinental Title: Seth Rollins vs. The Miz vs. Finn Balor vs. Samoa Joe
Rollins is defending in a ladder match. It’s a free for all (later known as a Kickoff) to start with Rollins hitting a double Blockbuster and some suicide dives, including one to knock out the Arabic announce team. The first ladder is grabbed but it’s Balor hitting a big flip dive to take everyone out. Joe can’t get a ladder in so Balor does it instead and goes up, only to have Miz make a save.
This time it’s Joe going up with Miz making another save, meaning he’s ticked off Joe. It’s a shame that Maryse will have to raise the new baby on her own. Joe starts wrecking people with the ladder until Balor hits a Sling Blade and the running dropkick to knock Joe into the ladder. Rollins breaks up a Coup de Grace onto the ladder onto Joe but gets planted on the worst part of a Tower of Doom. Miz hits Joe in the face with the ladder and goes up, only to be caught by Rollins.
Balor makes a save and takes a neckbreaker, followed by Miz shoving Rollins of the ladder. More ladder shots take out Rollins and Balor again but Finn is back up with a kick to the head. The Coup de Grace onto Miz on the ladder but Joe comes back in. The Koquina Clutch goes on for a few seconds with Balor slipping out and stomping on Joe again. Another ladder shot allows Balor to climb but Rollins springboards in and pulls the title down in a flash to retain at 14:29.
Rating: B. That ending was sweet with Rollins barely being involved for a few moments and then literally jumping in to retain. Rollins looks like an even bigger star than usual and that’s the way they should have gone. They’ve got something with him right now and it makes sense to push the heck out of him. It’s even better that no one had to job here with Balor, who was close to the win, not looking bad in defeat. Good match, though the NXT ladder match is going to outshine any ladder match for a LONG time.
Video on the Saudi Arabia tryouts.
Four people who did well in the tryouts are presented to the crowd and talk about what it was like. Cue the Daivari brothers with Iranian flags (Saudi Arabia and Iran DO NOT get along) to say this is how real athletes look. The trainees clean house before a war breaks out.
We recap the Smackdown World Title match. AJ Styles beat Shinsuke Nakamura at Wrestlemania but Nakamura turned heel and attacked AJ’s groin for several weeks. Tonight is the rematch with Styles very ticked off.
Smackdown World Title: AJ Styles vs. Shinsuke Nakamura
Styles is defending. They fight over a wristlock to start and I’m not exactly feeling the anger and hatred so far. A quick trip to the floor leads to a hard lockup back inside and a COME ON from Nakamura. What might be the Wave breaks out as Nakamura kicks him down and grabs a long chinlock.
AJ fights up with a facebuster and a shot to the face to rock Nakamura. The fireman’s carry backbreaker gets two but Nakamura hits a facebuster. The Calf Crusher goes on for a bit until Nakamura rolls away for the break. Nakamura hits the running knees in the corner as the fans are trying to get back into this. AJ sends him head first into the buckle to slow Nakamura down but still gets pulled into the cross armbreaker.
Styles stacks him up for two and scores with the Pele for another double knockdown. The referee nearly gets knocked down so Nakamura gets ANOTHER low blow but AJ grabs the rope. Kinshasa is broken up with a forearm and they fight to the floor with a tackle taking Nakamura over the announcers’ table for a double countout at 14:28.
Rating: B. This was getting really good but I get why they went this way. The big rematch at Backlash can see Nakamura win the title for good, possibly with the help of a turning Anderson and Gallows. I liked it better than the Wrestlemania match, at least somewhat due to the lower standards. There’s chemistry there, and the emotion stemming from the low blow helped.
Post match AJ beats the heck out of Nakamura, including a slingshot forearm to the floor.
Cole: “Next up, the return of the Dead Man!” As in the guy who wrestled earlier this month.
Video on Undertaker. His opponent is never mentioned.
Rusev vs. Undertaker
Casket match. Undertaker, with a streak of red across his forehead (it looks like faded lipstick), follows Rusev to the floor and slugs away. More right hands in the ring follow, one of which puts Rusev onto the closed casket. Rusev’s right hands have little effect so Undertaker hits the apron legdrop.
Aiden English won’t let the casket be closed so Rusev hammers away and even gets the Accolade on. Undertaker powers out and the slugout is on with Undertaker hitting the chokeslam. Rusev gets tossed into the casket, followed by a chokeslam and Tombstone to English. He’s thrown in next to Rusev and Undertaker slams the lid shut to win at 9:14.
Rating: D. This was a house show casket match and that’s not the most thrilling thing in the world. Undertaker was just doing the greatest hits here and that’s not exactly thrilling stuff. He’s old and banged up but can still chokeslam people, which is about all you can expect. Nothing to see here, other than Rusev losing all over again.
We recap the Universal Title match. Brock Lesnar beat Roman Reigns at Wrestlemania in a surprise and tonight is the rematch inside a cage, possibly due to WWE knowing the American fans aren’t going to cheer him no matter what.
Universal Title: Roman Reigns vs. Brock Lesnar
Brock is defending inside a cage. Forty five seconds in and Lesnar is at three German suplexes. Number four is followed by the first F5 less than two minutes in. Reigns slips out of a second and hits back to back Superman Punches. The third rocks Lesnar but Reigns goes up. Lesnar makes a save and pulls Reigns back in, only to get powerbombed out of the corner. Reigns sends him into the cage and hits a spear that looked like it was in slow motion.
Two more spears drop Lesnar for two and Reigns goes for the door, which Heyman slams onto his head. Another F5 gets two and Heyman throws in a chair. The gloves come off but Reigns hits the fourth spear for two. Reigns chairs him down and hits another Superman Punch. A big spear drives Lesnar THROUGH THE CAGE with Reigns following and rolling to the side, putting his feet on the floor. This means LESNAR wins at 9:15 though, because “his body hit the floor first”. Even though it didn’t as it was laying on the broken cage wall. They completely botched that finish.
Rating: F. I had to pause for a second from laughing so much. I have no idea what they’re going to do with Reigns now but my goodness they couldn’t have screwed that finish up worse if they tried. On top of that it was a terrible match with nothing but finishers over about nine minutes with the fans reacting to absolutely nothing. Terrible match as Wrestlemania XXXI looks more and more like a fluke every time.
Greatest Royal Rumble
90 second intervals with Daniel Bryan in at #1 and Dolph Ziggler is in at #2. They waste no time in going for the eliminations but of course neither can go anywhere. Bryan can’t suplex him over the top and they grapple in the corner a bit with no one getting much of an advantage. It’s Sin Cara in at #3 for some rapid fire kicks. The Swanton hits Bryan but Cara can’t get him out. Instead it’s Ziggler kicking Cara out but not being able to do anything with Bryan.
Curtis Axel is in at #4 and goes after Ziggler in the corner, pulling him back in for some reason. Mark Henry is in at #5 and headbutts Axel out but Ziggler and Bryan can’t get him out. Mike Kanellis is in at #6 with Cole talking about how famous Mike’s wife is. He’s out in about three seconds thanks to a Henry clothesline, leaving Bryan to try and choke Henry. Hiroki Sumi (looks like a sumo wrestler) is in at #7 for the big showdown with Henry.
This goes badly for Sumi, who is put out in short order, followed by Ziggler and Bryan getting together to dump Henry. Viktor is in at #8 and knees Bryan down but can’t slam him out. Instead Bryan armbars him over the top and we’re down to two again. Kofi Kingston is in at #9 and gets a nice reaction from the crowd. Things speed up a bit until Kofi is sent into the post, allowing Ziggler and Henry to pound away. Tony Nese from 205 Live is in at #10 to really crank things up. Some high flying drops a few people to little avail until Dash Wilder is in at #11.
There’s still nothing going on here so Hornswoggle is in at #12 to help pull Wilder out, followed by a Samoan drop to Kofi. Ziggler superkicks Hornswoggle to break up the Tadpole Splash and Nese’s running knee is good for the elimination. Primo Colon is in at #13 and promptly botches a springboard attempt. More nothing goes on so it’s Xavier Woods in at #14 to give the fans something to cheer for. Woods gets sent to the apron and Kofi is sent over, landing on Woods’ back.
They climb up together with Kofi diving off both of them, meaning it’s time to dance. Tony tries to join in and gets dumped as the intervals are all over the place. Bo Dallas is in at #15 to do nothing either so here’s Kurt Angle in at #16 to get rid of Primo and Dallas. Angle dumps Ziggler as well before shrugging off New Day. Scott Dawson is in at #17 to go after Angle, leaving New Day to double team Bryan. The short clock strikes again with Goldust in at #18.
Bryan is put on the apron but slides through the legs for a sunset flip out of instinct. Konnor is in at #19 and goes after Kofi as Woods tries to amateur wrestle Angle. Corey: “You can call that the stupidest move in the history of wrestling. Elias is in at #20, giving us Bryan, Dawson, Woods, Kingston, Angle, Goldust, Elias and Konnor. After a quick concert, Elias dumps Kofi, Woods and Konnor at the same time. Luke Gallows is in at #21 as Angle locks up Bryan’s ankle. There’s the Angle Slam but Elias dumps Angle. Dang that’s quite the rub.
Rhyno is in at #22 and hits some forearms until it’s Drew Gulak in at #23. Everyone keeps brawling and it’s Tucker Knight in at #24. Drew’s sleeper is reversed into a flip over the top for an elimination and it’s Bobby Roode in at #25. The Blockbuster drops Elias and a dropkick gets rid of Goldust. Dawson gets catapulted out and lands on the corner of the steps in a painful looking landing. Fandango is in at #26, sending Cole and Graves into one of their patented stupid arguments about how Cole knew it was him.
Some near eliminations go nowhere so it’s Chad Gable in at #27. The ring is starting to fill up and it’s Rey Mysterio in at #28 to wake things up a bit. A hurricanrana gets rid of Gallows but Fandango breaks up the 619 to Roode. Mojo Rawley is in at #29 to get rid of Fandango and it’s Tyler Breeze in at #30, giving us Breeze, Bryan, Rhyno, Roode, Rawley, Elias, Knight, Mysterio and Gable. Breeze is out at Rawley’s hands in just a few seconds and Big E. is in at #31. He throws pancakes at Knight and grabs an abdominal stretch before throwing him out.
Karl Anderson is in at #32 for a spinebuster to Roode but Big E. throws him to the apron. Rey hits the 619 on Roode and it’s Apollo Crews in at #33. Gable gets tossed and lands on his face. Nothing else goes on until Roderick Strong is in at #34. Backbreakers abound and a jumping knee gets rid of Rhyno after a long run. Randy Orton is in at #35 to the biggest pop of the match. He catches a diving Apollo in an RKO for the elimination and eliminations for Anderson, Rawley and Apollo in short order. Orton and Mysterio go at it until Heath Slater is in at #36.
That goes nowhere and it’s NXT’s Babatunde (never been on the show but stands about 6’10 and weighs over 300lbs) in at #37. Kicks and choking ensue until Baron Corbin is in at #38. Corbin pulls Elias to the floor and sends him into the steps before hitting Deep Six on Mysterio. A clothesline knocks Strong out of the air and Corbin dumps Roode. Strong is out as well and Titus O’Neil is in at #39….and slips on the way to the ring, falling flat on his face.
Dan Matha is in at #40, giving us…and I won’t bother listing them because Braun Strowman is in at #41 so a lot of people are going out soon. Babatunde and Matha are out, followed by Big E. Slater gets press slammed onto the NXT guys, leaving us with Strowman, Bryan, Orton, Elias, Titus and Mysterio. Braun shrugs them off as Bryan is nowhere to be seen.
Tye Dillinger is in at #42 and Titus is tossed. A parade of finishers drops Strowman but he’s not tossed. Mysterio is out, followed by Dillinger and Orton at Elias’ hands. Strowman is back up and knocks Elias to the down but not out. Curt Hawkins is in at #42 and tries to run back to the entrance, only to have Strowman run to the floor and bring him back. Strowman throws Hawkins inside and runs over Bryan, who was down at ringside and not eliminated. Elias sends Strowman into the post twice in a row but here’s Bobby Lashley in at #44.
The power game begins and Elias is eliminated, leaving us with Lashley vs. Strowman. That brawl doesn’t get very far as Bryan comes back in and hits the running dropkicks from corner to corner. Great Khali is in at #45 and looking even slower than ever. He chops everyone in sight but Strowman and Lashley get rid of him in just a few seconds, much to everyone’s benefit. A double clothesline put Strowman and Lashley down and MY GOODNESS Bryan’s chest is a complete mess. Kevin Owens is in at #46 and the big guys get Cannonballs. Bryan takes a Pop Up Powerbomb and it’s Shane McMahon in at #47.
Shane elbows Owens down and does the bad punching, followed by the tornado DDT. Bryan and Shane have the big staredown before kicking at Owens. Shelton Benjamin is in at #48 and starts beating on Bryan. Owens gets everyone to go after Strowman and it’s Big Cass in at #49. Wait what about Sami and Jericho? They were both announced for the match no? Shane hits the Coast to Coast on Braun and Cass grabs a fall away slam on Lashley. Chris Jericho (POP OF THE NIGHT) is in at #50, giving us a final grouping of Jericho, Bryan, Lashley, Strowman, Owens, McMahon, Cass and Benjamin.
Jericho goes right for Owens and dropkicks Cass to the floor (not out). Shelton gets clotheslined out and there are the Walls to Owens. Cass is back in with a big boot to Jericho but Lashley can’t superplex him, instead dropping Cass down with a brainbuster. Bryan is back up with the YES Kicks and Shane loads up another Coast to Coast, only to have Strowman chokeslam him off the top through the announcers’ table.
Lashley and Jericho are tossed by Strowman as we make sure Shane isn’t dead. Owens is tossed and Bryan goes after Strowman but gets kicked in the head. Cass gets rid of Bryan after about an hour and fifteen minutes. Lashley and Jericho were eliminated somewhere in there so we’re down to Cass vs. Strowman. Cass charges at him but gets crotched on the ropes, followed by a running shoulder to give Strowman the win at 1:17:23.
Rating: D. Yeah this was bad, mainly due to the match being so crazy long that it became more about surviving until the ending rather than caring about the match. I was much more bored here than annoyed or angry or anything, which doesn’t exactly help things. Strowman winning is fine and Bryan getting so far until Cass throws him out is a good way to advance the story, but this was a bad idea, showing how ridiculous it was to have this many people involved.
Vince McMahon comes out to present the trophy and a Saudi official gives him a special title to end the show.
Overall Rating: D+. And that’s being generous. This show just did not need to exist and really, nothing happened. A few matches at Backlash were advanced but it was nothing that couldn’t be done elsewhere. The crowd was only into it some of the times and a lot of the people in the white robes in the front row couldn’t have looked less interested. Throw in all the SAUDI ARABIA IS AWESOME stuff and this was a rough sit. It’s not a terrible show but it really, really didn’t need to be some big event. We’re done with it now though and that means it’s time to rapid fire the Backlash build.
You could have cut at least an hour out of this show (start with twenty minutes from the main event) and it wouldn’t miss a thing. Undertaker vs. Rusev didn’t need to happen and one or two title matches were skippable as well. It’s not the worst show ever, but it’s another good example of WWE overdoing things for very little value. Virtually nothing on here matters and that’s not how this was presented. WWE acted like this would be some mega show and while it was on paper, I’m likely to forget the results in about a week. Long and boring, but not terrible.
Results
John Cena b. HHH – Attitude Adjustment
Cedric Alexander b. Kalisto – Lumbar Check
Matt Hardy/Bray Wyatt b. The Bar – Elevated Twist of Fate to Sheamus
Jeff Hardy b. Jinder Mahal – Swanton Bomb
Bludgeon Brothers b. Usos – Double powerbomb to Jimmy
Seth Rollins b. Samoa Joe, Finn Balor and the Miz – Rollins pulled down the title
Shinsuke Nakamura vs. AJ Styles went to a double countout
Undertaker b. Rusev – Undertaker shut Rusev in the casket
Brock Lesnar b. Roman Reigns – Lesnar escaped the cage
Braun Strowman won the Greatest Royal Rumble by last eliminating Big Cass
Remember to follow me on Twitter @kbreviews and pick up the paperback edition of the WWE Grab Bag (also available as an e-book) from Amazon. Check out the information here:
https://kbwrestlingreviews.com/2018/03/23/new-paperback-kbs-grab-bag/
And check out my Amazon author page with cheap wrestling books at:
Rude? Nonsense? I certainly wasn’t trying to be rude. Just gave you my honest opinion.
See, this is what I mean. You guys seem to be basing your opinions on; “This, didn’t need to be a PPV”, “I expected more”, “What was the point?” So what? You’ll notice neither of you countered all the stuff that I point out as being good, and any show that has that much good stuff cannot be considered bad. What was the point of the Rumble match? I don’t know, and being completely honest, I don’t care. At the end of the day it made Bryan and Strowman look like the mega-stars that they should be, each of them broke Royal Rumble records, and the record that Bryan broke has been in place for over a decade. Maybe we’ll find out what it means, maybe Strowman’s earned himself a new title opportunity. But at the end of the day it was just supposed to be a fun show and what’s wrong with that? We got some great wrestling so I see no reason to complain.
*KB, please remove this one; meant to post this as a reply not a new thread. Thank you. 🙂
That’s because you can’t counter “I liked it”. Well yeah, I know that. I didn’t, and nothing you’ve said goes beyond “I liked it”. There’s nothing I can say that is going to change that and vice versa. I complained because I wasn’t entertained for the most part and was rather underwhelmed. If you weren’t, I’m glad you had a good time.
Like KB said, I didn’t answer all that because you can’t counter “I like it”. And I’m happy for you that you enjoyed it. But if really want my opinion, I’ll give it. Cena and HHH has a decent match but with no build I don’t care. Alexander and Kalisto had an okay match, sure. Hardy retaining is good but Mahal shouldn’t be in that position in the first place and we got another bad match from him so I don’t see how that is a plus, besides I didn’t really doubt the outcome. Styles and Nakamura had a better match but still nowhere near close what these two should be doing. Nakamura has been nothing but disappointing in his main roster run. Undertaker and Rusev had a decent regular match but a terrible casket match with an even more terrible ending. I still don’t know what Undertaker is doing here and burying people (litterly and figuratively) while he clearly retired last year. I don’t agree that the rumble match should just be fun. First of all, we already saw 2 rumble matches this year and we even saw the andré the giant and women’s rumble before wrestlemania. Those two rumbles were for a title shot at wrestlemania and the so called greatest royal rumble was for nothing. Breaking records is easy when you just add 2/3 more people to a match and I don’t see how breaking records makes the match any better. The match itself was mostly boring because it was too long and again it’s hard to invest in Daniel Bryan’s amazing performance when he didn’t do it for anything because nothing was on the line. On top of all that this show was about 6 hours long and I was completely drained at the end. Nothing wrong with a fun show but this show wasn’t my idea of fun at all. Glad you enjoyed it though.
Just to be clear, I wasn’t trying to say counter “I like it”, I was trying to say that you guys mostly agreed with me. KB, you gave most of the stuff I listed anywhere from a decent to good grade. I just find it confusing why you give most of the stuff a good review but because there’s just a couple of bad things you give it a “generous D+.” It just didn’t seem fair is all I was saying. As for Undertaker vs. Rusev; I completely understand people not liking the finish considering how over Rusev is right now, but I wasn’t at all surprised. I don’t know how much more clear WWE can be than they have been since 2015 that they don’t see anything special in the guy. And I wasn’t saying that Bryan and Strowman setting records was what made it good, I said they both had kick-ass performances. Remember years ago when WWE trolled the fans by eliminating Bryan in 10 minutes? Now, complete 180.
And I’m trying to say that I don’t agree with you at all :-P. I mean that. None of the matches really mattered and even if they did, they were really dull and the whole show was extreme long. I didn’t have fun watching the royal rumble match even without the fact that it was all for nothing. In my opinion KB was very generous with the ratings of the matches on this show and I agree with his end rating. Besides, look at the ratings KB gave: the bad stuff was really terrible! And the staple match was a disaster. Agree with it or not but the review is very well written and the reasoning behind it is explained. I don’t know what else to say.
There’s no reason to be rude and start doing that ” 😛 ” nonsense. I don’t think anything on this show was terrible at all. If you want terrible go watch the 2015 Royal Rumble match, or Battleground 2017; THOSE were terrible.
I thought that you were pretty harsh with your critique honestly; the show wasn’t a blow-away show but overall I thought it was really good. John Cena and Triple H had a great match, Cedric Alexander and Kalisto had a great match, Jeff Hardy retained over Jinder Mahal which could only be a plus, the IC Championship match was great, A.J. Styles and Shinsuke Nakamura had a FAR better match than they did at Wrestlemaniaand the finish means we’re only going to get more and better matches between the two, The Undertaker and Rusev had what I thought was a pretty decent match with Taker still looking good and Rusev getting quite a bit of offense, and the Royal Rumble match I thought was a lot of fun. You could argue it was too long but we still got a lot of fun surprises, some new faces, Elias looked really good, Daniel Bryan had the performance of the night and broke the all-time record, and Braun Strowman kicked ass in that match, breaking Roman Reigns’ record with 13 eliminations in a single Royal Rumble match and won the whole thing which was fantastic, can’t think of anyone better than Braun to win it. The show had its downside sure, but when you ended it with a D+ and called that “generous” I that that was really harsh and the argument that “this didn’t have to be a PPV” is really unfair honestly. This show was an easy C or C+, or maybe even B or B- in my opinion.
I’m not sure what to say on this as I found it rather dull at times. The battle royal was a lot of nothing save for Bryan and Strowman (Elias did look good) and the rest of it felt like nothing I haven’t seen many times before. For a show that they hyped up to this degree, treating it as almost equal to Wrestlemania, I was expecting WAY more.
And what was it all for anyway? A trophy? What are we supposed to do with that?
See, this is what I mean. You guys seem to be basing your opinions on; “This, didn’t need to be a PPV”, “I expected more”, “What was the point?” So what? You’ll notice neither of you countered all the stuff that I point out as being good, and any show that has that much good stuff cannot be considered bad. What was the point of the Rumble match? I don’t know, and being completely honest, I don’t care. At the end of the day it made Bryan and Strowman look like the mega-stars that they should be, each of them broke Royal Rumble records, and the record that Bryan broke has been in place for over a decade. Maybe we’ll find out what it means, maybe Strowman’s earned himself a new title opportunity. But at the end of the day it was just supposed to be a fun show and what’s wrong with that? We got some great wrestling so I see no reason to complain.
Did you see how they stole my finish to the Brock vs Roman match? I have been vindicated by history! Mwa ha ha ha!
Since Sami is of Syrian descent, I have a feeling that is why he didn’t show up.
Sure looked like it!
This show was not good at all like seriously it was a 5 hour boring ass house show. I’m shocked Triple H and Cena got a B+ as to me the match was slow, boring and that second spinebuster looked horrible. The IC title match didn’t need the ladder stip and the the finish to the cage match was hideous. Tbh this was one of the most boring/Botch filled wwe shows I ever seen. The only good to decent matches were the Wwe title match and the cruiserweight match.
Wow KB, I haven’t watched the show yet but I’ve read reviews and you probably gave the HHH vs Cena match the highest rating. Everyone was saying that both men botched a lot of moves.
Your overall rating is also suprising after a lot of B’s. But I’m guessing you brought it down because of it’s length and its uselessness as a big show.
Did you realize as well that the crowd was always up and about?
The length and all the yay Saudi Arabia stuff really hurt it.
Oh yeah the crowd was terrible. They started off hot and then it went downhill in a hurry.
I believe almost all the crowd that were present were casual fans that didn’t follow wrestling on a continuous scale.
They seemed to Pop for all the old generation guys and were dull for the new guys.
So didn’t Roman’s feet hit the floor first? I replayed it and it looks like it.