The Wrestling Observer Newsletter Awards Are Out
And…..yeah I can’t say I’m surprised.
It’s that time of year again. The Wrestling Observer Newsletter Awards have been released and that means it is time to hear about how bad WWE is, how great AEW is and how no one really knows any other promotions aside from those two and New Japan. As usual, some of these are going to be good, some of these are going to be in the middle, and some of these are going to either make you laugh or need an aspirin. Let’s get to it.
As usual, I’ll be skipping the MMA awards because they’re still not wrestling.
Wrestler Of The Year – Jon Moxley
I can get this, but the garbage brawls in the main events were starting to grate on me. It was almost always going to be him or Drew McIntyre though and that’s fine. Roman Reigns was great, but he was gone for about half of the year so it’s kind of hard to go with an amazing four months over a very good twelve months.
Most Outstanding Wrestler – Kenny Omega
Are you really surprised by this in any way, shape or form? It’s pretty clear that Meltzer thinks Omega is the greatest thing ever so him winning this is hardly a shock whatsoever.
Tag Team Of The Year – Young Bucks
They don’t hold the Tag Team Titles for most of the year but they’ve won the award five times before so…..yeah of course they win here, despite maybe not being in the top three teams in AEW.
Best Interviews – Eddie Kingston
Yep.
Promotion Of The Year – All Elite Wrestling
Some of you may be noticing a pattern emerging here and while this is far from some ridiculous pick, I think you might be starting to see how these awards are going to go. If you’re talking just WWE vs. AEW then yeah I can see it, but I’d take NXT overall if that’s an option (and fair enough if it wasn’t).
Best Weekly TV Series – AEW Dynamite
It’s a toss up between this and NXT, though Ring of Honor’s Pure Tournament stuff was quite good. Again though: with a six month hiatus, how much praise can you really give them? Same with NXT UK, though the hour being chopped off is a helpful tool.
Match Of The Year – Kenny Omega/Hangman Page vs. Young Bucks
That’s what I had too.
MVP Awards
USA – Kenny Omega
Japan – Tetsuya Naito
Mexico – Rey Fenix
Europe – Walter
Non-Heavyweight – Hiromu Takahashi
Women’s Wrestling – Bayley
These continue to be the most pointless awards of the year, but given that Fenix wrestled in Mexico FIVE TIMES in 2020 (and not at all from March 7 – December 12), I think there might be some better candidates.
Box Office Draw Of The Year – Conor McGregor
The guy fought once for 40 seconds in January. This is a totally realistic comparison to wrestlers appearing for free on television 52 weeks a year.
Feud Of The Year – Jon Moxley vs. Eddie Kingston
I had it on my list of options but went with Bayley vs. Sasha Banks instead. Part of the problem is they only had two matches, one of which was thrown onto TV because of Lance Archer being held off the show. The promos were great, but I could go with a bit more than something that lasted about five weeks, started out of necessity more than a plan, and had some pretty obvious results.
By the way: that is now eight awards (not counting ones including MMA or the regional MVPs) and AEW has swept the year. WWE’s lone win: their international developmental champion who didn’t appear for six months and wrestles elsewhere.
Most Improved – Britt Baker
I could see this one, but I’m really not sure I can go with it. Bobby Lashley had a banner year and seemed primed to FINALLY move into the main event. Roman Reigns is the best heel in years (again: time issue). Bayley found every groove you could want as a heel. But then there’s Main Event Jey Uso, who may I remind you is JEY USO IN THE MAIN EVENT. Baker was very good and I don’t see it as some horrible choice, but Uso blows this away for me, just due to the surprise factor alone.
Most Charismatic – Maxwell Jacob Friedman
If you go with the stuff before the Inner Circle, it’s hard to argue. Sidenote: Orange Cassidy got second place. Isn’t his thing that he doesn’t have charisma or energy or anything close to it 90% of the time?
Best Technical Wrestler – Zach Sabre Jr.
That guy is so good with this stuff that he scares me, mainly because I don’t know how he is doing what I’m watching. I’d say that qualifies (and it has for seven years in a row now).
Best Brawler – Jon Moxley
His brawls aren’t even that great. I’m not sure who I would give this to, but I don’t think it’s Moxley. Lance Archer maybe? His are a bit more entertaining a good chunk of the time.
Best Flying Wrestler – Rey Fenix
I mean, he misses a lot of stuff but there are times where I can’t believe what I’m seeing from him so yeah I’m good with this too.
Most Overrated – Bray Wyatt
One day I’m going to need to get a definition of overrated, because it seems to be a lot closer to overpushed than anything else. And hey: WWE won something! Sure it’s a negative award but the streak is broken!
Most Underrated – Ricochet
Again: who thinks Ricochet is underrated? People are begging for him to be more regularly pushed. That’s not what underrated means, at least anywhere else. By the way: this is now 24 years in a row (and 27/28) that a WWE wrestler has won this award.
Rookie Of The Year – Pat McAfee
I would have been actually mad if this had been ANYONE else.
Best Non-Wrestler – Taz
I had Pat McAfee as he barely wrestled, but Taz is a fine choice as he has revitalized his career.
Best Television Announcer – Excalibur
Not until he learns how to properly say “combination”. Excalibur isn’t the best commentator on either show he appears on, nor is he anywhere close to the best in the business today. That goes to the criminally underrated Ian Riccaboni, who makes wrestling sound like a sport, makes Nickelodeon and TGIF references and seems like the nicest guy in the world. This is the most wrong of all the choices, but I guess commentary stopped being about telling stories etc. and becoming more about knowing who invented an armbar in Japan thirty years ago while wearing a mask and insulting JR for suggesting that Mid-South was good.
Worst Television Announcer – Michael Cole
Is that who is under Excalibur’s mask?
Best Major Wrestling Show – Revolution
I didn’t even have to look it up. I’m going to assume that Takeovers don’t count as major shows because I need to keep my blood pressure low and move on.
Worst Major Wrestling Show – Super Showdown
It’s the only show where I felt guilty for watching it so I think that qualifies.
Best Wrestling Maneuver – One Winged Angel
You knew this was coming as that’s 4/5 years in a row. I can’t wait for someone to kick out of that thing so we can stop acting like it’s the legdrop or Stunner.
Most Disgusting Promotional Tactic – WWE Releases Wrestlers While Making Record Profits
And no. Back in April, WWE released a few dozen wrestlers. Some of the names included:
Eric Young
EC3
Mike/Maria Kanellis
Aiden English
Heath Slater
Curt Hawkins
Sarah Logan
Primo/Epico
No Way Jose
Curtis Axel
There were other names and yeah some of them (Rusev/Good Brothers) felt pretty ridiculous. But look at that list of 12 names and tell me who had any serious value in WWE. Not who COULD have had value, but which of them was more than house show filler at the time of/within let’s say six months of their release.
Yeah it sounds harsh that they were released, but WWE isn’t a charity and as William Regal once said, no one owes you a living. The same is true of the agents who were furloughed: there aren’t as many shows taking place, so what are they supposed to get paid to do? I get the knee jerk reaction to this (and I had one as well because it was so shocking), but WWE has done this kind of spring cleaning for YEARS (not as much recently, but it’s hardly some unheard of idea) and it wasn’t a big deal. Low level wrestlers got released. That’s not disgusting.
You know what is? Matt Hardy flying off of a lift, slamming his head onto the concrete and being cleared about three minutes later so he could climb the set to do a stunt to end a match with Sammy Guevara at All Out. What WWE did was business (not nice business, but business). What AEW did with Hardy was disgusting.
Worst Television Show – Raw
At least it didn’t have Tommy Dreamer as a featured star, a still going feud over a wad of money, a portal to another dimension so the wrestlers could have a reality show, Eric Young as World Champion and a whodunit over a manager getting shot at a wedding by someone who was changed into another personality by cologne. Oh or another promotion coming in to constantly point out how pathetic the show is. I can’t imagine how badly that show would be seen. The more I read these things, the more convince I am that I’m the only person who watches ROH and Impact.
Worst Match Of The Year – Bray Wyatt vs. Braun Strowman (Swamp Fight)
I went with that too, though if you want to go with an actual match, that time where Matt Hardy’s head bounced off of some concrete and he continued the match in a few minutes because AEW’s concussion protocol can be done faster than defrosting a frozen General Tso’s chicken might qualify.
Worst Feud Of The Year – Braun Strowman vs. Bray Wyatt
That’s kind of hard to argue.
Worst Promotion Of The Year – WWE
AEW’S OWNER IS COMING TO IMPACT WRESTLING EVERY WEEK TO TELL THEM HOW MUCH THEY SUCK AND IMPACT’S OWNERS ARE COMPLETELY OK WITH THIS!!! As usual, fans think that Raw is all WWE does and as usual, those people are wrong.
Also, the Most Disgusting Promotional Tactic Award was related to WWE’s business practices. Those practices are making them millions upon millions upon millions of dollars a year, not counting the latest (yes latest) BILLION dollar deal that they announced early in 2021. Yeah they have one bad TV show, but they probably make more in a month than most promotions do in a year. Now what’s worse: a bad TV show from a company making no money or a bad TV show from a company making more money than we could ever hope to spend in a lifetime?
Best Booker – Tony Khan (AEW)
You knew (wait for it)
Best Promoter – Tony Khan (AEW)
It was coming (there you go)
Best Gimmick – Orange Cassidy
When your gimmick is being lazy, I’m not sure how much praise it is worth. At least he’s back down in the midcard where he belongs.
Worst Gimmick – The Fiend
It won Best Gimmick in the year of a DQ inside the Cell and wins Worst Gimmick here. What a fickle bunch. I’d probably go with Dexter Lumis, but I get that he has an audience.
Best Pro Wrestling Book – Killing The Business (The Young Bucks)
I have a wrestling bookshelf across the room from me, plus a pile next to me at the moment. Between those we have:
The Eighth Wonder Of The World (Bertrand Herbert/Pat Laparde)
Under The Black Hat (Jim Ross)
Rowdy (Ariel/Colton Tombs)
Master Of The Ring (Tim Hornbaker, which I don’t own but want to pick up)
Take any 320 pages out of those (it can be from any book in any order) and I have a feeling it’s going to be better written/more interesting than the Bucks’ story.
Documentary Of The Year – Owen Hart (Dark Side Of The Ring)
That wasn’t even the best episode of the season, but I can go with it for the emotional impact.
Final tally (ignoring awards for things other than wrestling/regional MVPs and one off wins from outside the big two):
AEW – 19
WWE – 10 (8 negative, with Underrated being kind of a negative as well)
I have no issue buying that AEW was better than Raw, Smackdown and NXT, but come on with some of these. Raw for Worst TV Show? Cole as Worst Announcer? Excalibur as Best Announcer? WWE as Worst Promotion (again: IMPACT IS HAPPY WITH AEW COMING OVER AND INSULTING THEM!)? The Bucks get book of the year?
I’ve said many times before that there is no such thing as being unbiased in reviewing (it’s literally impossible). That’s all well and good, but there is a difference between being somewhat biased and just picking what you like and going against what you don’t like. These awards have felt like they are more the anti-WWE awards for years and if that’s what the people voting think then rock on, but good grief with some of these.
WWE wasn’t great in 2020, but it’s not like AEW was that much better. These would have you believe that 2000 WCW was laughing at WWE and it just wasn’t that bad. I’m not upset about any of them (save for the Promotional Tactic deal, which was just dumb) but I’m also not surprised by some of the most ridiculous ones.
You and this comment section are nothing more than brainwashed morons. You piss on Dave Meltzer for having a bias, yet you refuse to acknowledge that WWE has legitimate problems. Never mind the fact that NXT always gets a pass, because if Dave was this anti-WWE shill, why would he give a so-called “farm territory” the respect it deserves while criticizing the so-called “main roster” for its many, many faults? The only thing about these awards that suck are the fact they put over MMA despite being a pro wrestling-centric outlet and they never acknowledge any other promotion not named AEW. But no, you all think Meltzer and these awards are bullshit on the basis that they make WWE look bad, as if they needed any help in that department.
You are pathetic, this website is pathetic, and this comment section is everything wrong with professional wresting. Get over yourselves.
You said the Owen Hart “Dark Side Of The Ring” wasn’t even the best episode last season. Which do you think it was?
I liked the UWF one best. If nothing else for going into such details on a lesser known subject. To be clear: the Owen one was great as well and almost any episode would have been acceptable.
Thanks for reminding me what a bunch of meaningless horseshit these awards are.
Clearly, Impact was not even considered here as nobody should win worst announcer while Matt Striker lives and breathes.
Also, almost every big company laid off people during the pandemic.
Between that and voting a guy who made billion dollar deals as “worst promoter”, the voters and Big Dave clearly know little to nothing about economics.
Then again, these are probably the same people wondering why someone would go to WWE to make more $ to feed their family instead of getting a bigger push and a shiny belt in a smaller company.
Meh, I don’t even pay attention to Meltzer’s awards. I only clicked here so I could read KB’s take on them. Even before I clicked, however, I knew the general formula would be something like New Japan/AEW = Good, WWE = Bad. And yeah, I was right.
While it’s true fans vote on these awards, these are fans who pay money to read Meltzer’s stuff. As a result, these are people who, for the most part, see pro wrestling exactly how Meltzer does and what he says is pretty much gospel. Not to say that some of the choices aren’t legit and worthy of winning, but some really aren’t.
If you look at how you rate AEW vs NXT you give AEW the up in quality almost every time.Your playing it up a little bit
A few things: Honestly the WWE attempting to control all of the extra curriculars of their “Independent Contractors” i.e. Twitch, Youtube, Cameo, etc. is far more disgusting than their yearly releases. But I would consider neither of those a “promotional tactic” I don’t know, what is that even? AEW lettting Matt Hardy continue to wrestle after falling 20 ft. directly onto concrete could have KILLED HIM. I don’t think I am over stating that. I agree with you on your assessment of that “Award”
I for one enjoy all the silly over the top stuff that Impact does, it is part of their identity. In my opinion it was FAR from the worst weekly show, and to me it keeps getting better. I find AEW’s “Paid Adds” to be humorous but not overly harmful, but I can understand where you are coming from.
Finally, Thank you for giving Ian Riccaboni the credit he is due for being one of if not the best Play-by-Play wresting announcer going right now. He has only been calling matches for 5 years but sounds like a seasoned pro. He is fantastic and deserves far more credit for making ROH that much more enjoyable.
You thought Impact Wrestling’s weekly T.V. program should’ve been given “worst show” over WWE Raw? Not saying you’re wrong, but just surprised since it seems like you always give Impact decent grades on your show reviews.
When Impact focuses on the wrestling instead of the goofy stuff, it blows Raw away. When Impact is doing their stupid bits and focusing on people like Tommy Dreamer, it sinks to far lower depths. Overall, neither is good but Raw doesn’t get that bad most of the time.
Hey KB,
This is from a comment I read in another forum:
Shouldn’t the best promoter be the one who has generated the most revenue or profit for their company which should be Vince based on the deals made every year.
Also from a booking perspective, I find NXT to be more consistent among other shows.
Regarding Raw, I would consider it to be more boring than bad. I was going through average raw ratings across years and it has always curved towards C grade more often than not.
I understand that the voting is done by the members and not especially Dave but won’t the readers prone to vote towards what Dave has consistently made his opinion towards which is WWE bad others good? Before AEW it was NJPW which used to be his preferred option.
What’s your take on that?
That’s the definition of a promoter so yeah. For as good as AEW has done in a short time, they’re drawing about 800k a week or so on average in prime time on one of the biggest cable networks. That’s impressive, but WWE’s minor league is competitive with their A show and Raw/Smackdown regularly double (and more) AEW’s audience, with Smackdown on a much bigger network. Throw in all of their other deals and it isn’t a comparison (again: not a knock on AEW, but they’re up against the biggest company in the business which has a 40+ year head start).
Booking: yeah I like NXT better, but at least it’s something you can compare.
Absolutely that’s the case. It’s like saying people who watch MSNBC tend to lean left or people who watch FOX News tend to lean right. People who read Meltzer are going to lean towards him and he can’t stand WWE. There’s nothing wrong with that opinion, but to suggest that Meltzer isn’t a massive influence on the awards is nonsense.
These awards were voted by readers of metlzer not picked by the man himself. You get that right? Your phrasing indicates that you seem to think Meltzer picked these.
Also while conor McGregor did have a short match, he still made more money than anyone else in one match so what’s the issue there? That makes him the biggest box office draw.